Fuel Great Indian Rock- 2010 Final List

Fustercluck · **Joined:** Wed Nov 03, 2010 4:33 pm **Posts:** 96

What is wrong with you idiots? Deal with it. If you don't like it, don't come . Its really simple. You live in India, you deal with worse shit everyday, so fucking deal with this.

6StringEvil · **Joined:** Wed Nov 03, 2010 8:57 pm **Posts:** 54

sharmanator wrote:

Insanemuthafuka wrote:

whitepony wrote:

mat aa phir. forums mein bhee mat likh. go bitch it out on gigpad.

Are you gonna introduce yourself before I tell you to fuck off?

Are you gonna keep it low before i throw you out of the whole forums?

matlab zabardasti mein hero banne ka ?

Insanemuthafuka · **Joined:** Wed Nov 03, 2010 7:57 pm **Posts:** 334

Stop free speech = Stop evolution. 8-)

JITS.. · **Joined:** Wed Nov 10, 2010 1:54 am **Posts:** 46

@pradeep..chill bro..Juice piwanu..Majaani Life..

maggot · **Joined:** Mon Nov 08, 2010 3:46 am **Posts:** 202

sharmanator wrote:

N00pDawg wrote:

@ Dhruv -: if your favorite band is not there , then dont come bro . The festival is not made by the inclusion of just 1 band . You need to realize that sometimes , the decision is not in our hands . We are not dumbfucks sitting here catering to the needs of every individual . We need to look at the larger picture .

I like the band . Im making efforts to promote them so that they can make it to GIR . You should do the same instead of whining .

Diya.

cybernetic fuel to the flame

maggot · **Joined:** Mon Nov 08, 2010 3:46 am **Posts:** 202

Insanemuthafuka wrote:

whitepony wrote:

the only excuse for not taking Scribe on is to possibly promote 100% fresh talent. But this is hardly fresh.

You think Scribe is fresh? :roll:

again i say.. you are obviously too lame to be using 'insanemuthafuka'

sharmanator · **Joined:** Wed Nov 03, 2010 4:56 pm **Posts:** 27

maggot wrote:

Insanemuthafuka wrote:

whitepony wrote:

the only excuse for not taking Scribe on is to possibly promote 100% fresh talent. But this is hardly fresh.

You think Scribe is fresh? :roll:

again i say.. you are obviously too lame to be using 'insanemuthafuka'

@ the first post: haha
@this one: Diya.

maggot · **Joined:** Mon Nov 08, 2010 3:46 am **Posts:** 202

N00pDawg wrote:

JITS.. wrote:

Isnt it possible or why cant RSJ have a rule of sorts wherein bands who have consistently played at GIRs in previous yrs are not considered for the next 2-3 yrs or so..Nothing against the established names but as a fan would love to see more of new/fresh bands & talent..If the big bands are the benchmark..then i guess you will end up seeing the same big names every year..Its like predicting that out of the 12....6 bands are in there for sure..& i am sure if you have been around u know who they are..

The established acts need to pave way for the rest..That is if they allow them to do so..These bands need to look beyond GIR..& the new ones need to showcase themselves at GIR which is one of the biggest platforms in this country .is that too much to ask for ? & yeah there are many established acts out there who havnt played at GIR too..

It aint about BIG vs small bands..its about channelizing talent in the right way to actually make the most out of a music festival which every indian rock fan looks forward to every year.

+ 1

100 sonar ki 1 lohar ki

- 1 guy out of 100 who is in the same thought process as we are

oye wisdomtooth.. listen.. that +1 would hold good.. if DR and BM werent playing either... If scribe is left out because they are established and you wanna leave give a spot to younger bands (which i think is what gir is about anyway) .. then how do you explain DR n BM. how much more established do you have to be than DR ?

now if you took Scribes spot cuz they have played so many years in a row... then yes it makes sense to do it.. but again.. not this year.. they just released an album this year.. they should be playing in their home turf ( sahil dont correct me ). if scribe has been playing for the past 5-6 years then its not their fault is it.. maybe you should have thought about it after the first 2-3 and said.. meh... lets take a break from that for a while. but instead you manage to fuck up da game when they are probably in their hottest form yet.

on related note... id like to say the same thing i said on fb... scribe BM DR atleast these three shouldnt have to send entries and compete and be selected to play GIR. you already know how good they are and they cant be any more established within the scene itself.. what does one have to do to be treated olike a respectable band ? and if we dont treat our own like they should be.. then which white country would ? anyway I think its high time that rsj invites certain acts to play as headliners.. and leave the sending entries to the younger less established bands

Asmo.Ani · **Joined:** Mon Nov 08, 2010 9:04 am **Posts:** 330

maggot wrote:

on related note... id like to say the same thing i said on fb... scribe BM DR atleast these three shouldnt have to send entries and compete and be selected to play GIR. you already know how good they are and they cant be any more established within the scene itself.. what does one have to do to be treated olike a respectable band ? and if we dont treat our own like they should be.. then which white country would ? anyway I think its high time that rsj invites certain acts to play as headliners.. and leave the sending entries to the younger less established bands

+1 to this. If certain acts are established as DRAWS (and by that i mean can pull in an audience) and will bring in a crowd, they shouldn't have to send in entries. I think I-Rock manages to format its lineup in such fashion rather well. So part 1 of Day 1 is reserved for the less established bands, while the rest are slotted mostly on their experience and drawing power (which when combined, form their price)

I'm curious here, do bands selected for GIR via the entries route get paid?

sharmanator · **Joined:** Wed Nov 03, 2010 4:56 pm **Posts:** 27

maggot wrote:

N00pDawg wrote:

JITS.. wrote:

Isnt it possible or why cant RSJ have a rule of sorts wherein bands who have consistently played at GIRs in previous yrs are not considered for the next 2-3 yrs or so..Nothing against the established names but as a fan would love to see more of new/fresh bands & talent..If the big bands are the benchmark..then i guess you will end up seeing the same big names every year..Its like predicting that out of the 12....6 bands are in there for sure..& i am sure if you have been around u know who they are..

The established acts need to pave way for the rest..That is if they allow them to do so..These bands need to look beyond GIR..& the new ones need to showcase themselves at GIR which is one of the biggest platforms in this country .is that too much to ask for ? & yeah there are many established acts out there who havnt played at GIR too..

It aint about BIG vs small bands..its about channelizing talent in the right way to actually make the most out of a music festival which every indian rock fan looks forward to every year.

+ 1

100 sonar ki 1 lohar ki

- 1 guy out of 100 who is in the same thought process as we are

oye wisdomtooth.. listen.. that +1 would hold good.. if DR and BM werent playing either... If scribe is left out because they are established and you wanna leave give a spot to younger bands (which i think is what gir is about anyway) .. then how do you explain DR n BM. how much more established do you have to be than DR ?

now if you took Scribes spot cuz they have played so many years in a row... then yes it makes sense to do it.. but again.. not this year.. they just released an album this year.. they should be playing in their home turf ( sahil dont correct me ). if scribe has been playing for the past 5-6 years then its not their fault is it.. maybe you should have thought about it after the first 2-3 and said.. meh... lets take a break from that for a while. but instead you manage to fuck up da game when they are probably in their hottest form yet.

on related note... id like to say the same thing i said on fb... scribe BM DR atleast these three shouldnt have to send entries and compete and be selected to play GIR. you already know how good they are and they cant be any more established within the scene itself.. what does one have to do to be treated olike a respectable band ? and if we dont treat our own like they should be.. then which white country would ? anyway I think its high time that rsj invites certain acts to play as headliners.. and leave the sending entries to the younger less established bands

Only indian bands without even a single album out should get to play GIR? :p

Fuel Great Indian Rock- 2010 Final List

Who is online